Centenary in ¾ Time: Celebrating Philip Glass’ 75th Birthday
Compared to composers who have passed on, music by those who are still alive remains relatively underperformed, or at least obscure. Of course, the same could be said about a number of dead composers, whose names escape me at the moment. As he turns ¾ of a century today, Glass has established a reputation as one of the best-known among the living. Part it is negative, deriving from the perception of “repetition” in his works. Of course, those who dismiss Glass’ music for that reason are listening superficially, or they do not allow themselves to grok the subtle textures and transitions that unfold to reveal a richness which belies his “minimalism.” (At least Otto, the bus driver on The Simpsons, likes it.)
Perhaps without the expectation of hearing a “concert” in the traditional sense, it becomes easier to let Glass’ music work its magic. It should be allowed to breathe, and fill the space that you allow it within your soul. Listen closely, for instance, to the first 15 minutes of Music with Changing Parts (1971). I remember first hearing it back in 2003 or 2004, when Diane and I were returning home to Arlington, Texas, from a Saturday night spent in Dallas. She bought a recording at Borders (R.I.P.), and we listened to it on the way home. She drove, so it was easy for me to let the music and the nocturnal atmosphere envelop my senses. The car’s clock kept its tally, but time seemed to have gone missing. Perhaps I had gone on a vicarious trip through the universe?
Although I listen to other musicians and composers more frequently, I still count Glass as one of my favourites. His music may be a stark contrast to my fanboyish tendencies towards WagnerMahlerStrauss, but it works during those times when I want to enter a more meditative state of mind. Indeed, as I write this posting and listen to Music with Changing Parts, a warm orb seems to have formed around my heart.
My enjoyment of Glass’ music preceded hearing Music with Changing Parts. I already had recordings of Glassworks (1981) and a collection of violin works containing his Concerto for Violin and Orchestra (1987). Diane’s interest in Glass expanded our mutual collection of his works. With social media sites that provide access to multimedia files, it has become easier to access his work. There’s also the Glass Engine, an online tool that categorizes his music by such facets as title, year, track length, and emotion; (From an information retrieval perspective, the less said about it, the better…) But even earlier than that, I remember watching Koyaanisqatsi (1982) on PBS sometime in the mid-1980s, probably when I was 12 or so years old. I was not yet back “into” classical music, broadly speaking, but I remember being mesmerized by the riot of visuals and Glass’ (at least to me) unique sound. (Koyaanisqatsi is a Hopi word that roughly translates to the film’s subtitle “Life out of Balance.”) Some visuals may act as temporal reminders of the period in which it was created, but it otherwise remains transcendent of time. Out of temporal habit, however, this posting seems appropriate for commemorating Glass’ position in this time and space.
[Ah, yes! And there are all those cross-genre connections. David Bowie, Brian Eno, Ravi Shankar, etc., etc., but detailed discussion of those will have to wait for another day.]
Auferstehung(?)
For starters, I’m not purporting to put myself at the same level as Jesus, Gustav Mahler, or Robert Powell. Nonetheless, the title for this inaugural reboot posting (“resurrection”) of Geheimnisvolle Musik indicates a renewed commitment on my part to keeping this blog up-to-date. Content will likely include commentary on interesting stories related to music, or on studies related to the categorization of music.
In the blog’s initial incarnation, the majority of postings focused on personal experiences with finding similarities among different kinds of music. As time allows, that content will be condensed into a single document. The current postings, now in a reverse-chronological format broken up by other postings, will disappear once the new document is up.
Why the major lull in postings? Well, I started doctoral studies in September 2010, and I have tried getting a handle on how to balance everything (coursework, various part-time work positions, etc., etc.). Now that I am finished with coursework and moving on to preparing for my comprehensive examination (which essentially consists of reading several thousand pages and showing “what I know” at some point several months from now), my time isn’t necessarily “freer.” It is more flexible, fortunately, and I can manage broader swaths of time more effectively. Since my coursework has covered such topics as critical theory, information equity, politics and aesthetics, content analysis, cognition, and so on, I hope to apply some of the insights I’ve gained to discussion of the issues addressed in this blog. I have also completed a book chapter that dissects genre’s pervasiveness as a mode of music categorization, and advocates alternative modes to facilitate greater musical discovery. That will appear in a book my spouse Diane Neal is editing (Indexing and Retrieval of Non-Text Information), which will be published by De Gruyter Saur in May.
So, with that, feel free to join in the discussion. Civil comments, spirited discussion, and even some of your own cross-genre associations are always welcome here.
Gershwin’s the Word
Okay… someone already took my original idea for the article title, but the allusion isn’t far off.
Anyway, something else related to crossing genre: Brian Wilson doing an album of George Gershwin, with some samples on his Website. It underscores musical and cultural connections across genres, and that somehow make sense.
Fascinatin’.
Pandora Pandemonium
From The Onion, a story about Pandora employees desperately trying to please a man who kept disliking the songs on his personalized “Steely Dan Radio” station. Assumptions are made about what Mr. Lipton (the listener) might like, and a “panel of genre-bending musicians” is even convened to figure out how to get him to stick with a song. At the end, one of the panelists determines that Lipton is “probably just some bored, bitter asshole who isn’t capable of genuinely enjoying anything.”
Interestingly, The Onion didn’t ask Lipton himself why he kept skipping songs. We are only left with the impression of someone difficult to please.
In Lipton’s defence, perhaps Pandora is making assumptions that are all wrong. The story is, of course, an exaggeration, but it hints at deeper truths about such systems. How they rely too much on making selections based on genre, with selected artists as the primary guide. Even the biggest fans of certain musicians do not love everything by their favourites.
The solution is to look past musicians and genres, and to develop more sophisticated systems that make recommendations based on common characteristics that transcend genre. This can be for people whose stations cover a broad range of genres, or for those who wish to explore music outside the genre (or even subgenre) they typically listen to. In such a scenario, perhaps Mr. Lipton would be happier with the selections made for him… and Ms. Stefano of Milwaukee wouldn’t keep listening to Physical Graffiti over and over and over…
Summertime, and peggin’ genre is easy
Tied in with the CBC Radio Two Program Tonic, a selection of three different interpretations of “Summertime” from George Gershwin’s 1935 opera Porgy and Bess. One of them, of course, features an opera singer (in this case, Leontyne Price). The other two are by musicians typically associated with other genres: Ella Fitzgerald and Janis Joplin, respectively representing jazz and rock/blues… generalities that I proffer with some hesitation.
It may seem a bit odd initially to consider that musicians from diverse genres would perform a piece from an opera. But then, “Summertime” is so ubiquitous that it can practically stand on its own. With the song’s origins in African American musical styles, it makes sense that jazz, rock, and blues musicians (or at least those typically labeled as such) would perform the song, as well as opera singers.
Much else informs the overall style of Porgy and Bess. For more details about Gershwin’s eclectic musical development, Alex Ross’ The Rest is Noise provides a rich overview within the span of six pages (143-150). Interestingly, the preface of Ross’ book describes a 1928 meeting between Gershwin and Second Viennese School composer Alban Berg. Upon hearing Berg’s Lyric Suite, Gershwin worried about the worthiness of his own compositions. After hearing the American perform some of his own works on piano, the Austrian reassured him by saying, “Mr. Gershwin, music is music.” In a way, Gershwin repaid Berg by incorporating some of his musical ideas (most especially from his 1925 opera Wozzeck) into Porgy and Bess, which premiered the same year Berg passed on. Gershwin followed a few years later.
University: Wie schön…
(Part VI of “Mein Heldenleben: A Musical Autobiography”)
A slight digression, but this posting will return to the chronological sequence established before…
Alex Ross’ 2007 award-winning book The Rest is Noise is a highly-readable and accessible overview of the past century’s musical history, as well as an examination of the past century through its music. Although “classical” composers remain the book’s central focus, Ross eschews traditional musical narrative by colouring quite a bit outside the traditional lines of genre. He examines the fuzziness of such boundaries, drawing substantial attention to a number of artists one wouldn’t imagine appearing in such a book. Film composers. Jazz musicians. Rock stars. The same can be said about those who have praised the book, ranging from pianist Emanuel Ax to Radiohead’s Colin Greenwood to Björk, who aptly describes it as an “incredibly nourishing book [that] will rekindle anyone’s fire for music.”
In the first chapter (“The Golden Age”), Ross makes the bold assertion that the musical history of the 20th century begins with Richard Strauss’ opera Salome, based on the play by Oscar Wilde. More specifically, Ross refers to the Graz premiere in May 1906. Salome actually premiered on 9 December 1905 in Dresden, but Ross chooses to start with the Graz performance because it was attended by many of the major musical luminaries of Europe. (Rumour also has it that another attendee was a 17-year-old near-penniless malcontent, who would bring the continent to its knees 30 years later.) Ross contextualizes Salome by describing the wide-reaching aesthetic influence of Wagner, whose musical ideas Strauss simultaneously appropriates, expands, and (according to some scholars) parodies in a rejoinder to the Romantic ideals promulgated by his predecessor. This becomes most apparent in the opera’s final scene, a Grand Guignol twin of the Liebestod from Tristan und Isolde. (If you were expecting audio, sorry about the final scene image. A sample of the final scene itself appears later.)
After performing The Dance of the Seven Veils for her lecherous stepfather Herod, Salome engages him in a battle of wills to obtain the severed head of the prophet Jochanaan (John the Baptist) as payment. Herod’s desperate pleading with Salome to accept any of his other treasures fails. He finally gives in, and the opera careens towards its inevitable conclusion. In the final scene, which lasts somewhere around 15 minutes, Salome displays a number of emotions upon receiving her ghastly reward. Vindictiveness. Tenderness. Sadness. Ecstasy, upon kissing Jochanaan’s mouth. After the figurative and literal climax near the very end, where Salome enters a state of near-cosmic ecstasy, Herod abruptly orders his stepdaughter’s execution.
Naturally, the powers-that-be expressed concern about the opera’s content. Such concern apparently enabled Strauss to build his villa, as audiences went wild for his latest succès de scandale. As the success of controversial rock albums in more recent times indicates, plus ça change…
Beyond its scandalous aspects, Strauss’ opera is noteworthy for a number of other reasons. With the 1889 premiere of Don Juan, Strauss began to develop his reputation as a musical enfant terrible. Ironically, his personal life was fairly quiet and conventional. His marriage lasted longer than the entire lifetimes of some composers, and he enjoyed playing cards and drinking beer with friends. He also grew up in a contentious household, witness to his father’s abusive treatment of his mother, who ended up institutionalized. For this reason, as Ross aptly puts it, Strauss was “determined to maintain a cool, composed façade, behind which weird fires burned” (Ross 14). Perhaps his connections to Salome and Elektra (the topic of his 1909 opera of the same name) were deeper than many realized, and that his musical portrayals of their dysfunctional families were more than just masterful tricks of orchestration.
Subsequent premieres of his works were awaited with eager anticipation within the music world, even if critics had a field day demolishing them. The Graz premiere of Salome, with its aforementioned gathering of major present and future names in “classical” music, was no exception.
Ross describes the ambiguous tone world of Salome, embodied by the otherworldly opening notes of the clarinet, as well as the free-flow and convergence (even collision) of different realms of sound. Although the opera takes place in biblical times, Ross postulates that the sounds could just as easily portray a contemporary urban environment:
There’s a hint of the glitter and swirl of city life: the debonairly gliding clarinet looks forward to the jazzy character who kicks off Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue. (Ross 7, 2007)
When I read Ross’ comparison of the openings to Salome and Rhapsody in Blue (just the first few seconds or so from each are necessary for understanding), I felt vindicated in having made the same connection years before. Perhaps Gershwin gave a sly nod to Salome in the opening of his jazz-infused tribute to the hustle and bustle of New York City. I would even go so far as to say that the lonely saxophone theme from Bernard Herrmann’s mid-1970s score to Taxi Driver shares similarities with the music by which Salome persuades the ill-fated captain of the palace guard to bring up Jochanaan (Du wirst das für mich tun, Narraboth…).
Perhaps Strauss had unwittingly tapped into a musical language about which he would have known little or nothing. He visited the United States for a tour in 1904, where he premiered his Symphonia Domestica at a Wanamaker’s department store in New York. Even if Salome contains some elements that sound vaguely like precursors of jazz, no record exists of him encountering the music that would eventually evolve into that genre. The slang term would come into common use a decade later.
When Strauss toured the United States again in 1921, the Jazz Age had already begun and Rhapsody in Blue would premiere a few years later. As outlined in the third and fourth chapters of Ross’ book, a number of composers had actively begun to incorporate jazz elements into their works. And yet, even as late as the 1950s, the notion of a classical musician discussing jazz seemed a bit of a novelty among the general public.
Kurt Wilhelm’s Richard Strauss: An Intimate Portrait contains what appears to be a typical Q&A from the press conferences to which Strauss would submit during his 1921 visit. One question consisted of his thoughts on jazz. His apparent response:
I have heard some in Europe. Very interesting, especially the rhythms. (Wilhelm 165, 1989)
Strauss wrote no explicitly jazz-infused compositions, and likely had no intention of doing so. He had already begun to focus on less-agitated works than Salome and Elektra, rendering him “obsolete” to composers who claimed to be moving musical language “inevitably” into the new century and beyond.
Strauss lived until 1949, witnessing and trying to survive as best he could the horrors brought on by that same 17-year-old who claimed to have attended the Graz premiere of Salome. Ross aptly contextualizes Strauss’ lifespan… born before Wagner finished his epic Der Ring des Nibelungen, and passing on as “American soldiers were whistling ‘Some Enchanted Evening’ in the streets” (10).
Another 43 years passed before my revelatory experience with Salome. I already had a few versions of the The Dance of the Seven Veils, a final scene conducted by Fritz Reiner, and one of the most the iconic complete recordings of the opera (Nilsson, Solti, Vienna Philharmonic, Decca). In the summer following my first year at university, I obtained a filmed version that really brought home to me the power of Strauss’ opera. It is the 1974 Götz Friedrich film with Teresa Stratas, whose singing seems more aptly spritely and youthful than Nilsson’s Valkyrie-sized portrayal. Her acting is also incredible. A diva in the truest sense, Stratas dashes about, pouts, cries, pleads, and zeroes in on the object of her character’s desire with unbridled intensity. Karl Böhm, a conductor who had worked with Strauss during the composer’s later years, whips the Vienna Philharmonic into a vivacious frenzy. Under Böhm’s guidance, the orchestra unleashes horns and timpani with ferocity (as one can note here, especially around 5:00 and 6:40), and plays up a number of the opera’s shimmering dissonances. The final scene is also available here, beginning around 2:20 or 4:30 (starting points for standalone recordings of the final scene vary, but I recommend starting earlier for the full effect). It continues here and here.
This, or something like it at least, is how it should sound, I thought.
I sought other Salome recordings that would enable me to explore its mysteries. Luckily, the first few years of the final decade of the 20th Century proved a bumper crop for interpretations of the Salome story… both in recordings of Strauss’ opera, and in two songs by a rock band with whom I had yet to acquaint myself.
The first recording of Salome I obtained after viewing the film was led by Giuseppe Sinopoli, whose spacious interpretation of Pietro Mascagni’s Cavalleria Rusticana prompted me to seek out his version of Strauss’ opera. Two other versions led by Zubin Mehta and Kent Nagano (the first full-length recording of the French version) were also released in 1991… the same year U2 released its single of the same name, and included the Salome-themed Mysterious Ways in the album Achtung Baby. (The Smashing Pumpkins rounded out the most recent fin de siècle with Stand Inside Your Love, its music video alluding heavily to Aubrey Beardsley’s illustrations for Wilde’s play.)
It would be another decade before I started listening to U2. I will say that I have noticed Straussian elements in some of the band’s songs, including the rhythmic similarities in the openings of “The Dance of the Seven Veils” and “Mysterious Ways.” But more on all that later, in the interest of staying with a more conventional chronologial narrative…
Coming to an orchestra near you… Video game music
Once again, from Alex Ross, an interesting post worthy of comment and contemplation. Included is a trailer for a PBS special called Video Games Live, which features an orchestra playing music from video games. This tactic is apparently being employed by orchestras strapped for cash in already economically dire times. From the looks of things, it is an immersive experience, complete with visuals to remind audience members what the music is portraying. Speaking for myself, it seems a bit overwhelming, and dictates too much what one might be better off imagining… especially if the target audience is already well-versed in the “plots” of various games. That audience consists of young people who might not have dreamed of going to a symphony orchestra.
Ross does have some misgivings with which I agree. As he says, “If the video… successfully captures the video-game-concert experience, I would pay good money not to have to see it.” Nonetheless, I do agree in principle (if not with the execution featured in the clip) with the idea of video game music being a way of introducing young people to the sonic wonders of orchestral music. Thinking of John Williams and his film music, it is essentially the same idea. Both video game and film music share a number of similarities, including the intention of accompanying pre-crafted cinematic experiences (as opposed to the generally stage-based experience of opera), as well as flexibility in the kinds of genres that both types of music may incorporate. Much of what appears in the clip sounds firmly rooted in the “classical” realm. Interestingly enough, it also brings to mind the idea of the “total art work,” rendered into the single German word Gesamtkunstwerk.
Richard Wagner coined this term in the mid-19th Century, applying it to works of art that could incorporate all art forms… design, literature, and performance. The opera house he had built in Bayreuth for the performance of his own works aided in realizing this vision. The hidden orchestra pit ensured that audiences would focus on the stage, and that their eyes wouldn’t wander to the musicians. Completed in 1876, the principles of Bayreuth seemed to presage those of cinema, wherein audiences see premade gesamtkunstwerken in theatres with well-hidden sources of sound. A century after Wagner launched Bayreuth with his multi-part mythical epic Der Ring des Nibelungen, George Lucas brought it home with his own mythical cinematic epic that drew upon similar principles…right down to the Wagnerian soundtrack by John Williams.
Video games are yet another extension of Gesamtkunstwerk. The difference, of course, is that their audiences actively participate in guiding the action… at least insofar as programmers allow them to do so. When George Lucas released his original Gesamtkunstwerk, the video game experience was limited to things like Pong. Now, video games have become substantially more immersive, making them more and more similar to the theatrical ideas promulgated by Wagner.
Don’t believe me about the similarities between opera and video games (or, more specifically, Wagner and virtual reality)? A book has already brought those ideas together.
As more immersive gesamtkunstwerken emerge, and if some young people can learn more about the predecessors of the music that accompanies the games they play, perhaps the process will come full circle.
Classical music is tight yo
Via Alex Ross, via Anastasia Tsioulcas, via… Kanye West’s Twitter feed.
Before they get buried too far down, some other notable tweets from West’s account (which he apparently started just a few days ago):
29 July 2010 (Around noonish?)
“William Tell” Overture by Andre’ Rieu … Maybach music!!!
Leonard Bernstein is the shit!!! Hit flute player is snapping write now!!! Are those Christmas bells?
In New York!! 105.9 plays the hits!!!!!!!!!
That is “The Classical Music Station of NYC“
And…
Classical music is tight yo
Keep spreading the good word.